Provincial Governance

Northern Fur Conservation Area Agreement

Summary

This ten year agreement, jointly funded by the provincial and federal governments, allowed the province to create a Fur Advisory Committee that would advise the government on matters of conservation on trapping above the fifty-third parallel, which was divided into five ‘fur blocks.’ These regions were allotted to five-member trappers councils who were responsible for overseeing the conservation endeavors. Trapping was restricted to those who had lived in the north for at least a year (to shut out seasonal trappers from the south) and who had no other major source of income outside of trapping.

Implications
The main implication of this event is the restriction of movement of people in the trapping industry. What is meant by this is that people cannot trap outside of a certain area. In doing so, this locks trappers, who are mainly Indigenous in this area to a parcel of land in relation to their occupation. While this measure is designed to stabilize the population of fur bearing animals, it has the effect of becoming another controlling measure rallied against predominantly Indigenous people.
Date
1946-07-18

Creation of Union of Saskatchewan Indians

Summary

The Union of Saskatchewan Indians was formed in 1946 as a provincial Aboriginal political organization. It was created with assistance by Saskatchewan Premier T.C Douglas. John Tootoosis was the first president of this group, which was the amalgamation of three previously existing groups: the Protective Association for Indians and their Treaties, the Saskatchewan Indian Association, and the Saskatchewan section of the North American Indian Brotherhood. Aboriginal members of the union had voting privileges, but persons of any race were eligible for non-voting honorary membership. The choice of John Tootoosis as president was hoped to bring together First Nations people from the north (treaty 6) and the south (treaty 4) into one united organization.----------Premier T. C. Douglas began to take a more direct role in Indigenous affairs after July 1945, when members of the Carry-the-Kettle Reserve (Dan Kennedy's reserve) conferred on him the honorary title of Chief Weagasha (Red Eagle). The work of T.C. Douglas and his legal advisor Morris Shumiatcher seems to have irritated some bureaucrats in the federal government, who viewed this active involvement with First Nations organizations as provincial meddling in an area of exclusively federal jurisdiction. It was also known that Douglas wished to have federal services to Indians transfered to provincial governments.

Implications
David Quiring suggests that, because of Douglas's involvement in the creation of the organization, it was strongly allied with the CCF. In some respects, the Union might have been undermined by activities of settlers who often assumed that they were better aware of the interests of Indigenous people than Indigenous people themselves. In the end, the CCF involvement in the creation of a unified provincial Indian organization presented both benefits and consequences. On the negative side, the enemies of the government sometimes became the enemies of the Union. The antipathy of the Roman Catholic Church, as well as the Saskatchewan Liberals, damaged the Union. Although Douglas claimed a desire for Indigenous people of Saskatchewan to unite, he also had a goal of what the future of Indigenous peoples in Canada should look like - integration with the mainstream population.
Date
1946-00-00

Creation of Saskatchewan Fish Products and Saskatchewan Fish Marketing Board

Summary

In an attempt to regulate fisheries and establish a product of uniform quality, the CCF government created the Saskatchewan Fish Products board to operate filleting plants in the province, and later in the same year created the Saskatchewan Fish Marketing Board. Several shipments of fish had been refused at the American border, due to the presence of bacteria found in Saskatchewan lake fish, prompting the government to increase quality inspection and establish quality standards. The SFMB applied many of the same policies that the SFMS did to furs: licenses for local fishers and regulation of fish prices were central to their goals. In 1946, the board was reorganized with the creation of the Saskatchewan Lake and Forest Products Corporation, which included three divisions: fish, timber, and the Box Corporation. The goal of the board was to encourage participation in the fish industry, especially by Indigenous peoples, and to create a government monopoly over the sale and trade of fish. The board also established six stores throughout Northern Saskatchewan as a Crown corporation in order to regulate the purchase and sales of goods in the fishing industry. The board also effectively served as a social services board until it was eliminated in 1949 after years of deficit.                      

After the failure of the Saskatchewan Fish Market Board to stabilize fishing industries, it was reorganized in 1949 to create the Saskatchewan Fish Marketing Service. Fisheries were then structured by region, which were administered by one central administration. An interview with Berry Richards reveals that one purpose of the Fish Marketing Service was to give Indigenous fishermen a better price than paid by private fishing companies. However, this was not the case as many Indigenous fishermen reported that what they received from the Government was substantially less that what they received from private contractors. They were also unable to negotiate better prices for their catch, as they had with private buyers, because the Fish Marketing Service came from a top-down standardized approach which did not allow for negotiation. 


 

Result

The top-down approach the CCF took towards fish marketing, despite intentions to assist Indigenous fishers, ultimately created problems from new restrictions with fishing permits. Indigenous fishers who had previously accessed many different lakes found that they were prevented from fishing if they did not have a permit to continue. This furthered barriers to food and engaging with livelihoods which supported life in the North. Fishing without permits could result in a fine, multiple fines over a period of time, or in some cases incarceration. Similar policies were replicated by the CCF in their implementation of the Fur Marketing Service, another poorly devised program that bought the lives of Indigenous people in the North under further scrutiny. Please see "CCF Social Programming and Erosion of Traditional Life in Northern Saskatchewan" which details how the implementation of these programs undermined Indigenous livelihoods and increased reliance on welfare and social services, an outcome the Provincial Government sought.   


 

Sources
  • Glenbow Archives, M125 James Brady Collection, v. III, "Correspondence, 1933-67," f. 22, "Norris 1945-67 (Mining and Native Rights)," M.F Norris to James Brady, December 5; S-M15, Box 7, "Fish Marketing, 1945-1946," April and May1948 Fish Board Operation Statement; S-M15, Box 8, "Lucas, A.A., Office Manager, Fish Board, 1946-1948," Lucas to Phelps, 24 January 1947; S-M15, Box 9, "Sask. Lake and Forest Products Corporation, 1946-1949," H.H Lucas, Address on mechanics of STB, 16 January 1948; J.F Gray to Phelps, 5 May 1947;
  • Thomas Hector Macdonald McLeod, "Public Enterprise in Saskatchewan: The Development of Public Policy and Administrative Controls" (PhD dissertation, Harvard University, 1959), 95.
  • Sask Sound Archives Program: Gus McDonald interview, 29 June 1977. 11-12.
  • Carl W. Christenson interview, IH-358, 12 August 1976. 3-4.
  • Saskatchewan Archives Board: S-M15, Box 6, "Fisheries, 1944-1946 (3)," Phelps to L.H Ausman, 19 September 1945
  • SM-15, Box 5, "Economic Advisory Board Recommendations, 1945-1946," DNR Activities Summary for 1945 and plan for 1946, 3
  • Richards, Berry. Interview by Murray Dobbin. Transcript. June 14, 1976. Virtual Museum of Métis History and Culture.Gabriel Dumont Institute. http://www.metismuseum.ca/resource.php/01134\
  • Quiring, David M. CCF Colonialism in Northern Saskatchewan. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2004. 128.
  • Piper, Liza. The Industrial Transformation of Subarctic Canada. Nature, History, Society. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2009. 218.

 

Sub Event
Establishment of Fish Marketing Board Stores in 1945. Reorganized as Saskatchewan Fish Marketing Services in 1949.
Fill

 

Date
1945-00-00
Region

Creation of Saskatchewan Fur Marketing Services

Summary

In attempt to regulate fur trading and trapping enterprises, the CCF government created the Saskatchewan Fur Marketing Services, a crown corporation commission service for trappers. The SFMS regulated prices and quotas on specific species to encourage conservation. Beaver and muskrat pelts had to be sold through this service, though other types of pelts could still be sold to private enterprises. The SFMS also took 10% of the revenue from the sale of pelts. The Department assured that the positions of First Nations and Métis trappers would be taken into consideration regarding the new regulations. Despite these assurances, there was organized opposition to this service, as evidenced by the Lac La Ronge petition of 1949, where 137 members of the area demanded that their furs not be sold by socialist bodies, such as the Marketing service.

Implications
Hunters and trappers (who were mostly Aboriginal) had fewer options for fur buyers and prices. The SFMS was unpopular among Aboriginal trappers and was abandoned by 1956. The reasons for this closure are several. One of the main reasons for the abandonment of the Fur Marketing Service was the mandatory nature of the program throughout its early years.

As per Robert Dalby, "...the trappers had to sell the beaver and muskrats (which is the principal crop) to the Fur Marketing Service in Regina. And they all resented it, without fail, you know… . And I think the intent was to give them a better price but for some reason it just didn't work properly.” (Saskatchewan Archives Board. Interview of Robert Dalbey by Murray Dobbin, for the oral history project “Biographies of Two Métis Society Founders.” Tape R-A1l48)

Another issue with the program was how it was imposed upon the population of Northern Saskatchewan. According to the book CCF Colonialism in Northern Saskatchewan: Battling Parish Priests, Bootleggers, and Fur Sharks there was no input from the people of Northern Saskatchewan, in the design and implementation of the Fur Marketing Service. Instead, people from the Southern half of the province were employed to design this program, among them being Joseph Lee Phelps, minister of Natural Resources and Industrial Development from 1944 to 1948.
Sources

‘Department of Natural Resources,’ Saskatchewan Commonwealth, 4 February 1948.

Barron, F. L. Walking in Indian Moccasins the Native Policies of Tommy Douglas and the CCF. Vancouver: UBC Press, 1997.144-145.

Date
1944-00-00
Region

Construction of Whitesand Rapids Storage Dam

Summary

In 1942-1943 the Churchill River Power Company constructed a storage dam at Whitesand Rapids on Reindeer Lake to stabilize the water supply for the Island Falls dam. The Peter Ballantyne Band is upstream from the Whitesands Dam at Southend Reindeer Lake. Six hundred acres of shoreline part of their reserve lands was flooded by the operation of the dam.


 

Result

The construction of this dam raised water levels in Reindeer Lake nearly five feet, and the outlfow south of the dam changed so drastically that the habitat became unliveable for muskrat, beaver and mink.  It also led to the destruction of spawning grounds and reduced fish harvests.  Local Indigenous residents were never compensated for their significant fishing and trapping losses, nor were they provided with alternative means to support their livelihoods. In addition, flooding represented more than a material loss; environmental destruction and the disappearance of key species in an ecosystem contribute to emotional, cultural, physical, and intergenerational impacts of colonialism within an Indigenous community. According to oral histories conducted by the Churchill Committee in March 1978, Pelican Narrows resident Alex Bear stated that very little consultation was undertaken with Indigenous residents when the Whitesand dam was built. He explains that the deeper water levels the dam created rendered net fishing impossible. Ernest McLeod, a resident of Stanley Mission explains how the high water levels flooded the muskrat nests, killing the animals in the process (Churchill Committee Brief to the Churchill River Board of Inquiry, 1978). 


 

Sources
Fill

 

Date
1942-00-00
Documents
File
File Description
Richard H. Bartlett. Hydroelectric Power and Indian Water Rights on the Prairies